We often hear stories these days about how humanity is hard done by – on the receiving end of some sort of natural disaster or bad luck from nature. This can take the form of wild animal attacks on humans or domestic animals, flooding or droughts, and so on.
We should stop for a minute and really look at these stories to understand what has changed recently to cause the current conflict. Has there been some alteration in nature’s patterns, have the animals decided to take different migration routes or change their diets?
In every case you will find that this is not the case. Nature is just doing what it has been doing for millennia. The change has come from humanity.
The examples are many and varied – from Brazil to Bangladesh, to Australia.
In Brazil farmers are illegally burning down the Amazon rainforest. Then they move in with vast herds of cattle. And then they start complaining that the jaguar population is taking an interest in their livestock. Well why not!!! The jaguars were there first, they eat meat, and if the farmers provide animals that don’t run away fast enough – Lunchtime!
The farmers have got absolutely no grounds for complaint. The land is part of the jaguars’ hunting range, they have been there for thousands of years, and certainly will not be fenced out. If the farmers don’t like it, they can go back to where they came from, or learn to live with nature.
Living on a riverbank that gets flooded every year does not make much sense. In Bangladesh the Brahmaputra and Ganges rivers having been rising and falling like clockwork with the annual monsoons. But in the last decade or so the locals started complaining that the floods were higher, lasted longer and occurred more frequently, and now someone else has to start protecting them with flood banks and the like.
How about looking a little way upstream instead! Ask who is sitting there and you will see 1000’s of people wandering around chopping down trees to use them for cooking fires! Why should we rush to try and help someone when the problem is only getting worse? Get back in the hills and get the trees planted again. That’s what ameliorates the floods, not big piles of sand and concrete everywhere.
There have been a number of severe bush fires across the south east of Australia in the last few years, and people are moaning about the bush management regime that the councils are running. Well the councils are trying to leave it to nature as much as they can, and they are actually doing a reasonably good job. So what is causing the increased fires?
How about looking at the ground and the bush – it’s a lot dryer than it used to be. A drought perhaps? Or then again perhaps it is the fact that the lifestyle of the population is sucking a lot more water out of the ground than it used to. There are more swimming pools, the population is spreading into dryer areas, and still want their green grass and pretty flowers, and agriculture is getting more intensive and water dependant. It all adds up to a lot more water coming out of the ground than is going back in.
So perhaps if the water was managed with a little more restraint than the current free-for-all draining of the trough, then there might be a little more left over for nature to keep itself green and less prone to going up in a puff of smoke.
So in every Humanity vs Nature story, we really need to look at Humanity’s behaviour before we run around bleating about how we get the raw end of the stick from nature.
The EU Capitulates to the Farmers, Again!!
October 21, 2009 by goodtalkingSo much for my hope that the EU had worked out a direction that would finally end the practice of pouring endless supplies of money into the bottomless pit that is Agriculture subsidies. http://goodtalking.wordpress.com/2008/05/21/eu-common-agricultural-policy/
French farmers have yet again thrown their weight (and a fair few eggs) around Brussels, and walked away with more of our taxpayer funds.
They claim that because governments have bailed out failing banks, they should be bailed out as well. Thrown out is what they deserve! They still expect us the taxpayer to fund their lifestyle, while they continue to build more butter mountains, or milk lakes, or whatever it is that is the current surplus product.
Its called a free market for a reason. If we want it, we’ll buy it. If we don’t like the price one supplier sets, we’ll go elsewhere to get what we need. The farmers can then adjust their prices or live with the consequences of funding an expensive lifestyle from one paddock of produce. Why should consumers pay more just to keep the farmers going on uneconomic production units. They need to look at their own cost structure before they can get another handout.
Banks were forced to look at their bonus culture when the governments saved them, so the farmers should expect the same sort of treatment. As UK Farming Minister Jim Fitzpatrick said – more subsidies are not acceptable if it leads to paying for production that nobody wants (http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/europe/8289976.stm).
When will we get some politicians in Brussels with the guts to take the right course for all of us, not just kowtowing to a select, obnoxious, minority.
Tags: agriculture subsidies, Brussels, EU, free market price, french farmer, milk, milk lake, protest
Posted in Political Commentary | Leave a Comment »